Sugar, often criticized for its adverse health effects, raises questions about its impact on athletes. While some sources vilify sugar, attributing it to issues like obesity, cancer, and cardiovascular disease, it's simultaneously endorsed as a vital energy source for athletic performance. This blog, the third in our series, delves into the crucial query: "Is sugar detrimental to athletes?"
Exploring Sugar Recommendations
Various organizations have put forth recommendations regarding sugar intake. The World Health Organization (WHO) highlights the risks of excessive free sugar consumption, linking it to dental decay and potential weight gain. Their counsel suggests limiting sugar to under 10% of total daily energy intake, which equates to about 12 teaspoons (50 grams) for adults. Stricter guidelines propose reducing sugar to less than 5% of energy intake for even greater health benefits.
American dietary guidelines echo this advice, recommending individuals aged 2 and above to cap added sugar at less than 10% of total calories. In the UK, free sugar intake is advised not to exceed 5% of daily intake. Despite some variations across countries, the consensus is clear: excessive sugar is detrimental to health.
Deciphering Sugar Types: Natural vs. Added
Sugar can be categorized as natural or added in our diet. Natural sugars are inherent in foods like milk and fruits, while added sugars are incorporated during processing. Though chemically similar, they may be packaged in different foods with varied nutritional profiles.
The Negative Health Impacts of Sugar
A wealth of evidence substantiates the adverse effects of excessive sugar consumption. For instance, a study of over 11,000 adults revealed that those consuming around 20% of energy from sugars had a 38% higher risk of cardiovascular disease mortality compared to those with an 8% intake.
While links between sugar and all-cause mortality, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, and high blood pressure exist, cancer claims remain unsubstantiated.
Understanding the Meaning of "Excessive"
Defining what constitutes "excessive" sugar intake is complex. Context plays a pivotal role. For instance, what's excessive for a sedentary individual might be appropriate for a high-intensity cyclist. Factors like carbohydrate balance and exercise timing further complicate the picture.
Debunking Glucose Spike Claims
The notion that sugar causes glucose spikes is multifaceted. Not all sugars yield substantial blood glucose elevations; fructose has a different effect than glucose. Exercise significantly influences blood glucose responses; even during exercise, glucose spikes can be managed. Transient changes in blood glucose shouldn't be confused with chronically high levels.
Sugar Intake and Fatty Liver
Excessive sugar intake contributes to triglyceride production and fatty liver disease, both risk factors for cardiovascular disease. However, these issues primarily stem from caloric excess rather than sugar alone.
Sugar Intake in Energy Balance
When consumed within energy balance, there's limited evidence of negative health effects associated with sugar intake. Studies often overlook the impact of exercise, a powerful modifier of glucose responses. Exercise improves insulin sensitivity, distinguishing it from chronically elevated glucose concentrations linked to poor insulin sensitivity.
Sugar Intake and Physical Activity
Exercise's impact on glucose responses is frequently disregarded in studies. Exercise enhances insulin sensitivity acutely and chronically. Insufficient consideration of exercise's broad effects is a prevalent shortcoming in nutrition research.
Exploring High Sugar Intake in Athletes
For athletes, particularly those engaged in prolonged exercise, higher carbohydrate and sugar intake may be recommended. During exercise, sugar consumption can fuel performance and replenish glycogen stores.
Navigating Sugar Intake for Athletes
Athletes should adhere to sports nutrition guidelines for peak performance, but also incorporate balanced nutrition for daily health. While sugars play a role in fueling workouts and aiding recovery, prioritizing nutrient-rich whole foods is crucial. Staying active and regularly utilizing carbohydrate reserves are key strategies.In essence, sugar's impact on athletes hinges on a complex interplay of factors, including energy balance, physical activity, and exercise intensity.
While recommendations provide population-level guidance, individual circumstances shape the actual effect of sugar on health. For athletes, sugar's role lies in performance optimization and rapid recovery, all within the context of a balanced diet.
If you have any questions, just drop us a message here we are always available 👌
Scientific References
- Yang Q, Zhang Z, Gregg EW, Flanders WD, Merritt R, Hu FB. Added Sugar Intake and Cardiovascular Diseases Mortality Among US Adults. JAMA Intern Med. 2014;174(4):516–524.
- Anderson JJ, Gray SR, Welsh P, Mackay DF, Celis-Morales CA, Lyall DM, Forbes J, Sattar N, Gill JMR, Pell JP. The associations of sugar-sweetened, artificially sweetened and naturally sweet juices with all-cause mortality in 198,285 UK Biobank participants: a prospective cohort study. BMC Med. 2020 Apr 24;18(1):97.
- Lean, MEJand Te Morenga, L. Sugar and Type 2 diabetes. British Medical Bulletin, 2016, 120:43–53.
- Moore JB, Fielding BA. Sugar and metabolic health: is there still a debate? Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care. 2016 19(4):303-9.
- Malin SK, Kullman EL, Scelsi AR, Haus JM, Filion J, Pagadala MR, Godin JP, Kochhar S, Ross AB, Kirwan JP. A whole-grain diet reduces peripheral insulin resistance and improves glucose kinetics in obese adults: A randomized-controlled trial. Metabolism. 2018 82:111-117.
- Jeukendrup, AE. Carbohydrate intake during exercise and performance, Nutrition, Volume 20, Issues 7–8, 669-677, 2004.
